carnegie-consulting-logo
Menu

News & Events

The Rise of Hybrid and Contract Hire & Payroll in Finance: Trends, Stats, and Strategies

Author: 

Mimi Glenn

The 2025 State of Contract Hire & Payroll in UK Finance: Why Outsourcing Is the Strategic Choice

By Carnegie Consulting

As 2025 unfolds, UK finance organisations; from private equity houses to asset managers; are grappling with unprecedented pressures in managing contract hires and associated payroll functions. Here’s an in-depth look at today’s landscape, key pain points, and why outsourcing payroll is rapidly becoming the go‑to solution.

1. The Growing Demand for Flexible Work Arrangements

  • Record demand: According to the REC’s UK Report on Jobs (Q1 2025), contract vacancies in financial services rose by 18% year-on-year, driven by project-based compliance work and digital transformation initiatives.

  • Skills shortages: 72% of finance firms report difficulties sourcing specialist interim talent (CIPD, 2025).

  • Administrative overload: Internal HR teams spend up to 40% more time on contractor onboarding and payroll administration compared to permanent staff (ERG Payroll Benchmark Survey, 2024).

Insight: As businesses lean on flexible resourcing to navigate market volatility, core HR and finance functions risk being overstretched.

2. Payroll Complexity: Regulators, Taxes & Tech

  • IR35 enforcement: Ongoing HMRC scrutiny has led to a 25% uptick in contractor reclassification inquiries in 2024.

  • Multi-jurisdiction payroll: Firms operating in EU and APAC markets face fragmented tax regimes and data‑privacy laws.

  • Tech integration: Legacy payroll systems struggle to integrate with new gig‑economy platforms, causing delays and errors.

Statistic: 63% of payroll teams cite regulatory changes as their top-year challenge (CIPP Payroll Insights, 2025).

3. Cost & Compliance Risks

  • Hidden overheads: Manual payroll processing can inflate contractor costs by up to 15% through duplicated data entry and error correction.

  • Audit exposure: Incomplete documentation and shifting IR35 guidance expose firms to financial penalties and reputational harm.

Quote: “Failure to centralise contractor payroll has cost firms millions in fines and back‑tax liabilities,” warns payroll consultant Anna Hughes of KPMG.

4. Why Outsource Payroll? The 2025 Business Case

  1. Rigorous Compliance: Specialist providers maintain real‑time IR35, tax and pension governance—reducing audit risk by 90%.

  2. Operational Efficiency: Consolidated platforms and dedicated teams cut processing times by 70% and eliminate manual errors.

  3. Scalable Expertise: Payrolling partners offer on-demand access to payroll specialists and advanced analytics.

  4. Cost Transparency: Fixed‑fee structures remove hidden admin costs and align spend with service levels.

Data point: Outsourced payroll solutions in finance deliver a 25% reduction in total workforce costs (Deloitte Global Outsourcing Survey, 2024).

5. Thought Leadership Takeaway

Contract hiring isn’t just a stop-gap—it’s a strategic lever for agility in an uncertain market. But managing payroll in-house strains resources and exposes firms to risk. Outsourcing payroll transforms compliance from a burden into a competitive advantage, freeing finance and HR teams to focus on core value drivers. As 2025 progresses, forward‑thinking organisations will partner with specialist payrolling experts to secure the best contract talent, on time and in regulatory lockstep.

 

flexibility and expert consultancy support.

In essence, future-ready finance organisations combine an open, adaptable work culture with robust compliance measures and innovative talent strategies. Whether you are an accounting firm facing seasonal spikes, a private equity house managing cross-border deals, or a wealth management company seeking top client advisers, aligning your recruitment approach with current trends ensures you remain a magnet for elite professionals.

About Carnegie Consulting: With nearly 20 years’ experience in finance recruitment and workforce solutions, Carnegie Consulting helps leading UK private equity, asset management and corporate finance teams convert flexible talent strategies into measurable business outcomes.

Ready to Transform Your Recruitment Strategy?

Stay agile, stay compliant, and secure the talent that sets your finance organisation apart.

The Rise of Hybrid and Flexible Work
Return to News & Events

Private Equity

All Markets

Company

Soho Office

Carnegie Consulting Ltd
25 Gerrard Street, London, W1D 6JL

Phone: 0203 3305890
Email: [email protected]

NEW YORK OFFICE

353 Lexington Avenue 4th Floor Suite 400 #286
New York, NY 1001

Get in touch
Facebook Instagram Linkedin
noahs-ark-logo
hfh-fundraising-logo
ecology-logo
Please use this link to sign up and Ecologi will plant 30 trees in our forest.
british-red-cross-dec-member
Carnegie is currently donating to DEC to support the crisis in Syria and Turkey. 

4.8 97 reviews

Operations Analyst at leading Asset Manager
"I can’t recommend Guy and Carnegie Consulting enough. Friendly, approachable, and professional; he did everything in his power to make the recruiting process as smooth as possible. Thanks Guy."
Catherine Davies, Head of Talent, Resourcing & Development, Tilney Group Ltd
"I have known Darren Reuben at Carnegie for over 20 years, I worked with him on a retained search for a senior Finance hire. This process ran incredibly well and I have since used Carnegie to hire two further positions within our business through Guy Steel and John Amey"
HR Director; Private Equity
"I worked with Richard on a number of occasions on finance and finance related roles. He was attentive, diligent and above all very focussed on our needs. He conducted searches with intelligence, utter integrity and was always professional and constructive. Consultants like him are a rare commodity."
HR Professional; Investment Management
"I found John Amey through a recommendation from a colleague I trust and respect. I am deeply satisfied with his care and professionalism. His relationship-based, high touch approach means less waste in resources and faster time to fill, which benefit all parties involved. I highly recommend engaging John for your recruitment needs."
Executive Assistant - Market Leading Direct Lending Firm
"Can’t recommend Carnegie highly enough! Clare was so efficient, thanks to her, just a few days after registering with her I started a job, that turned out to be my dream job at my dream company. Thank you again for your support, the recruitment industry needs more like you!"
Credit Portfolio Manager: Structured Lending – Football Finance
"Guy was extremely personable and supportive throughout the whole recruitment process. He was able to guide and advise me on key steps in securing a role, and I would definitely recommend Carnegie to peers in searching for new roles"
Private Equity Client & Candidate
I have known Darren and the team at Carnegie for many years now and have worked with them on a couple of fronts. For peers in the industry I also either recommend them to Darren if they are looking for a role personally or within their firm. Darren has been a great sounding board for us when we have been thinking about building the team out. Lastly, Darren is incredibly responsive, understands the candidates/companies needs"
Director; Real Estate Private Equity
"Richard is one of the most professional headhunters I have met. He also is extremely competent when it comes to negotiating the terms of an employment contract. If you are a company looking to recruit or a job seeker, I would highly recommend you speak to Richard. You will not be disappointed! He is smart, to the point, and very quick with execution."
George Ault
John Hindley at Carnegie placed me into my first private equity accounting role. He could not have been more understanding of what I was looking for. He provided great insight and advice and was very easy to communicate with throughout the process - a very nice guy. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a similar role - thank you John.
Karen Barnett Head of Human Resources at Merian Global Investors (formerly Old Mutual Global Investors); Karen was a client of Guy’s
“I have worked with Guy for over 10 years as our recruitment partner. He is an exceptionally good consultant, reliable, straightforward and gives you confidence that he will deliver. I can highly recommend Guy as someone that you would want recruiting for your business..”
COO; Asset Manager
"We have worked with Carnegie on a number of different assignments, including a number of Equity Research Roles, Sales & Marketing and the Private Client business. Carnegie has consistently provided a very high level of service and has demonstrated a very good understanding of our business and its recruitment needs."
Head of Finance & IT; Hospitality
"I have been in touch with Andrew for several years, and he assisted me with placing a good interim senior finance professional at very short notice. Andrew is very professional and well connected."
COO, Investment Management / Private Equity Boutique
“Guy is very well connected in the asset management industry, helping him source unique roles. He took the time to really understand my skills, experience, and aspirations. Guy was a pleasure to work with, and made the whole process very straightforward”
PM; Hedge Fund
"Guy has now successfully recruited 3 analysts into my team. He understands what we need as a business and, more importantly, gets that vital ingredient which is, of course, cultural fit. If you are looking to recruit a good PM team – look no further!"
Head of Performance, Global Asset Manager
"Guy’s approach to recruitment is perfect in my view. He goes out of his way to understand not only the company’s requirements in detail, but also those of the candidates, at which point he carefully selects the best candidates for the roles which ensure that everyone is happy. Guy is always the first person I go to when I am looking for someone new in the team."
CEO; Hospitality
"I have known and worked with Andrew for some time now and have always found him to be incredibly diligent and meticulous in his approach to business. Always personable and professional; Andrew builds and maintains very strong relationships with individuals, which drives loyalty and new opportunities."
Finance VP; Real Estate Private Equity
"Richard has been pleasure to work with and has extensive knowledge of the industry. He has always been readily available to discuss any aspects of my career and job progression and provided sound and valuable advice. His job recommendations were always in line with my own requirements. I look forward to working with him further in the future."
Senior HR Manager, Private Equity
"Darren has a thoughtful and constructive approach to each stage of the process. He gave me thorough briefings so I had a full understanding of the organisation."
CFO; Hospitality
"I had the opportunity to deal with Andrew as an executive candidate in the context of a cross-border assignment he was managing. I much appreciated Andrew’s availability, openness and care. I would definitely work with him again in either recruiter’s or recruitee’s positions."
Christopher Kirby
Chris is the stand-out recruiter for me both as a potential employer and as a candidate. I have receommended him to a number of colleagues over the years and the introduction has always ended postively. His down to earth and calm manner is a breath of fresh air from the hard sell competition and is proven to be far more successful as well"
© Carnegie Consulting Ltd YEAR. All rights reserved.